JEREMY RYTYCH
FOUNDER & PRESIDENT
Jeremy got started in the construction industry running a branch of Student Painters. Jeremy studied business at Ball State, perfected his business plan, and then went on to start a painting company. Then, Jeremy moved into working on the entire exterior: roofing, siding, and gutters. Jeremy started Element Roofing to set the standard in the roofing industry. He made Element Roofing into one of the top-rated contractors in Carmel, IN. Jeremy saw a statistic that said that roofers have the most complaints out of ANY business except used car salesmen, and he wanted to turn that around. So many so-called “roofers” come from out-of-state and perform shoddy work, offer little warranty, and are not to be found when an issue arises. This is why Jeremy founded Element Roofing on the core values of Customer Obsession, Be Real, Quality, and Embrace The Journey.
Jeremy grew up in Indianapolis, the son of Polish immigrants. He is proficient in 4 languages: Spanish, German, Chinese, and Polish. In his free time, he likes to travel, cook, play tennis, bike, snowboard, and wake surf. Jeremy resides in Carmel, IN.
MEHDI AYARI
SALES MANAGER
Mehdi brings a diverse background in sales, leadership, and international experience to his role as Sales Manager at Element Roofing. Originally from Tunisia, he immigrated to the U.S. at age 13 and later earned a BA in Journalism from Indiana University and a master’s in Political Science from Ball State.
Before entering roofing, Mehdi built a career across executive recruiting, legal marketing, international procurement, and government-funded research. He also taught as an adjunct professor and coached soccer at the high school, collegiate, and travel levels—experiences that sharpened his ability to lead, strategize, and connect with people.
At Element Roofing, Mehdi leads a driven, door-to-door sales team focused on helping homeowners through the insurance process with clarity and urgency. Outside of work, he lives in Fishers with his girlfriend and three kids, and enjoys playing and coaching soccer, working out, and following world politics.
Steven Henderson
PRODUCTION MANAGER
Steven Henderson is an accomplished Production Manager in the construction industry, bringing nearly a decade of experience to his role. Steven distinguished himself as an expert in developing efficient processes, with a commitment to delivering exceptional customer service. Prior to his current position, Steven built a solid foundation in Human Resources, where he honed his skills in communication, conflict resolution, and team dynamics.
Outside of his professional life, Steven is a passionate advocate for mental and physical health. He believes that maintaining a balanced lifestyle is essential for both personal well-being and professional performance. He enjoys playing and watching golf, as well as hiking in the great outdoors. Family plays a central role in Steven’s life. He cherishes the time spent with his wife and two children.
CAITLIN REXING
OFFICE MANAGER
Having graduated from Indiana University with a B.A. in Journalism and International Studies, Caitlin started her career in news media with NBC Universal. While in New York, she discovered her interest in startups and small businesses. After realizing that her talent and passion lie in assisting others in developing their businesses, she became a career Executive Assistant to CEOs and Presidents of growing companies.
Caitlin’s adventures with small businesses have taken her to live and work in New York, Maryland, D.C., and New Mexico. She was able to assist in vendor promotion of the Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show in 2009 and in securing New York City as the host of the 2014 Super Bowl working directly with the NFL Commission. She found her way back to Indiana, continuing to assist former classmates, friends, and professionals in creating and cultivating businesses that make a difference.
In her free time, Caitlin enjoys camping, climbing, swimming, and traveling. She can’t wait for the next adventure that awaits.
JOHN DILLE
SALES REPRESENTATIVE
John is a go-getter. He is passionate about sales and changing the perception of what salesman are. He comes to Element with a degree in Business Management and a minor in Communications from Indiana Wesleyan University. From financial services to sales, project management to customer relations, John has a strong background catering to the needs of customers and organizations. Although he enjoys working with customers and providing them with solutions for their roofing needs, his true passion is music and family. John has a loving wife of nine years and three young children who love to keep him busy.
In his spare time, John enjoys music, playing soccer, basketball and enjoys a good workout. His other passion is cars and going to car shows.
Nolan Armstrong
SALES REPRESENTATIVE
Nolan brings a diverse background in business, logistics, and customer service to his role at Element Roofing. He holds a Business Management degree from Anderson University and has experience working with companies like Amazon, Lyft, and Goldstar Management. His entrepreneurial drive led him to launch a personal development business focused on financial coaching.
Nolan’s work ethic was shaped early on the family farm, and today he channels that same discipline into helping homeowners navigate roofing projects with clarity and confidence. He’s known for his communication skills, reliability, and down-to-earth approach.
In his free time, Nolan enjoys anything outdoors—hiking, kayaking, playing sports, and staying active.
Melisa Sammy
ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT
Melisa Sammy is an experienced Administrative Assistant with over 20 years of expertise in customer service and office coordination. Renowned for her positive demeanour and exceptional communication skills, Melisa ensures the Element Roofing team remains organized and operates efficiently.
Her background includes everything from managing logistics and coordinating teams to providing top-notch support for clients and coworkers alike. Before joining Element Roofing, Melisa held roles across the Caribbean, including with CIBC, FirstCaribbean International Bank, and the British Council, where she mastered the art of multitasking, problem-solving, and keeping calm under pressure.
Whether she’s coordinating appointments, handling paperwork, or jumping in to solve a last-minute issue, Melisa does it all with a smile. Outside the office, Melisa enjoys spending time with her family, curling up with a good book, and staying connected with friends near and far. She believes that a good laugh and a positive mindset are just as important as a well-organized inbox.
Call (317) 548-8445 now to learn more about our roofing services and when you need a roofer in Carmel, IN or get emergency roof repair now!
